Home MTA Absurdity MTA entering the real estate biz for Second Ave. residents

MTA entering the real estate biz for Second Ave. residents

by Benjamin Kabak

cardboardbox.jpg

Hopefully, you won’t end up in that when the MTA can’t find you anything on Craigslist.

So last summer, when I moved back home to NYC after a few months away, I had to go through the joys of finding affordable housing in a city in which the vacancy rate is less than 1 percent. Now, less than 1 percent of a few million is still a significant number, and it’s not impossible to find somewhere to live. Just try finding a rent controlled apartment.

Ok, ok. Funny joke. Rent-controlled apartment. Ha ha ha. Stop laughing now because that’s just what the MTA has to do for those unfortunate souls living in the path of the Second Ave. subway. What makes this difficult task — finding affordable and comparable housing on the Upper East Side — even harder are the 60 rent-controlled apartments set to be demolished to make way for the new subway line. NY1’s transit reporter Bobby Cuza has more:

That’s right, the MTA is going apartment-hunting, trying to score cheap housing on the Upper East Side, the idea being to hold the apartments, then eventually hand over the keys to residents being displaced by the Second Avenue Subway.

“We are obligated to relocate most of these tenants – in fact all of the tenants,” said MTA Director of Real Estate Roco Krsulic. “We have to find them replacement housing. The rules are rather specific, that we have to find them comparable housing, and preferably in the same community board.”

Well, as a veteran of this process, I must suggest that the MTA start looking here on Craigslist but beware those finders fees. Another good place is The Times’ Real Estate listings, and this time, look out for photos and places that seem too good to be true. It’s a trap.

All joking aside, Krsulic’s department faces a daunting task. Metro’s coverage of this news was decidedly pessimistic. “Given the paucity of affordable housing in Manhattan, and especially on the Upper East Side, the Real Estate Department and our relocation consultants will be seeking potential replacement dwellings,” Krsulic said. “The possibility is we may not be able to find any.”

And that spells doom for a smooth start to this long and arduous subway construction plan.

You may also like

3 comments

wayne's world March 29, 2007 - 11:14 am

If the MTA has to pay a premium to relocate these people, it would be a very tiny percentage of the overall budget. So, there is nothing to stop them from allocating more money towards paying the living expenses of these people. Just part of the project costs.

Reply
MTA celebrates leasing their very first Second Ave. apartment « Second Ave. Sagas | Blogging the NYC Subways October 3, 2007 - 1:53 pm

[…] four apartment buildings on the Upper East Side. At the same time, the Authority must provide replacement housing for everyone they displace. The catch – of course, there’s a catch – is rent control. Most of these Upper East Side […]

Reply
real estate firms brooklyn April 22, 2009 - 12:03 pm

Interesting.

Reply

Leave a Comment