Home 2nd Ave. Subway History

2nd Ave. Subway History

by Benjamin Kabak

The following timeline is from the MTA. It details the history of the ill-fated Second Ave. subway line.

Early History

1920 Daniel L. Turner of the Public Service Commission published the “Proposed Comprehensive Rapid Transit System,” which included six new north-south lines and eight new crosstown lines in Manhattan. Scaled-down proposals from this report subsequently appeared in plans for a new City-owned Independent (IND) subway system, where the Second Avenue Subway was first mentioned. The IND plan called for a two phase system: Phase I would be the Sixth and Eighth Ave. lines, while Phase II would include the Second Ave. Trunk line.

1929 The NYC Board of Transportation proposed a Second Ave. line from Houston Street to the Harlem River for a cost of $86M. Contracts were expected to be let between 1930 and 1935, with the lines to go into service 1938-1941. In October, the Wall Street stock market crashed.

1931 While NYC suffered the effects of the Great Depression, the cost estimates for the IND Phase I were determined to be too low (by as much as 100%). Plans for the Second Ave. line were postponed. The new proposed opening date was 1948.

1939 The cost of the Second Ave. subway was now estimated to be $249M. New subway construction was suspended for the duration of World War II.

1942 Service ended on the Second Ave. El, and the line was demolished

1944 The Second Ave. subway was back in the planning stage, with some revisions. From Canal St. to 57th St. the line was to be four tracks, with six tracks north of 57th St. South of Canal St. there would be two tracks. Connections were planned for the lines from the Manhattan and Williamsburg Bridges. The planned opening date was 1951.

1949 The Second Ave. subway was now estimated to cost $504M. Queens residents promised not to approve the bond issue until promises were made for subway service improvements in Queens borough. The new R11 “million dollar train” was unveiled as the prototype train for the Second Ave. subway.

1950 The Second Ave. plan was revised again to include a two-track turnoff at 7th St., to 34th Ave. in Queens. A new subway under Northern Boulevard would connect to the LIRR line to the Rockaways. This plan cost $118M, of which $63M would come from deferring construction of the other part of the Second Ave. trunk line. The Korean War starts, driving up material costs.

1951 A bond issue for $500M was approved in November. The start of the operation was planned for 1957 or 1958.

1955 Service ended on the Third Ave. El in Manhattan. The line was demolished the following year. There was now only one rapid transit line (the Lexington Ave. subway) on the East Side of Manhattan.

1957 Transit Authority Chairman Charles L. Patterson used most of the $500M bond issue for improvements to the current system, leaving only $112M for the Second Ave. subway. The New York Times reported on Jan 17, 1957 (page 1): “It is highly improbable that the Second Ave. subway will ever materialize.”

The “First” SAS Construction

1964 The Urban Mass Transit Act was passed making Federal funding available for transit projects.

1965 The Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Authority (which became the MTA) was founded.

1967 A $2.5B bond issue for Transportation was passed. $1B was for urban transit in the state and $600M was for construction in New York City.

1968 The Second Ave. subway cost was estimated at $220 million for a two-track line from 34th St. to the Bronx (Phase One) that would would connect with the planned 63rd St. Tunnel and Central Park line. Phase Two would bring the line down to Water St. near the Battery. On September 20, the NYC Board of Estimates approved a two-track line from the Bronx to Water St., including the 63rd St. connection. To finance the first construction work–from 34th St. to 126th St.–the city applied for $254 million in federal funds, and an initial grant of $25 million was approved by the Urban Mass Transportation Administration. This marked the first time federal money was ever made available for major new subway construction in New York City’s history.

1972 Groundbreaking was held at East 103rd St. and Second Ave., 68 years to the day after the opening of the IRT.

1975 Construction of the Second Ave. subway was halted due to City’s financial condition. Only three non-contiguous sections of tunnel had been completed: between Chatham Sq. and Canal St., 99th and 105th, and 110th and 120th Sts.

The Current SAS Project

1995, MTA New York City Transit began the Manhattan East Side Alternatives (MESA) Study. This project was carried out as a federal Major Investment Study/Draft Environmental Impact Statement (MIS/DEIS). The MESA Study goal was to recommend a course of action(s) to reduce overcrowding and delays on the Lexington Ave. line, and to improve mass transit accessibility for residents on the far East Side of Manhattan.

In August 1999, the MESA Study issued a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) proposing a subway under Second Avenue from 96th Street to the 63rd St./Lexington Ave. subway station. At public hearings for the DEIS, strong support was expressed for evaluation of a “full length” Second Ave. subway.

On March 22, 2001, the SAS Study published a Notice of Intent in the Federal Register to undertake a Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement (SDEIS) to evaluate a full-length Second Ave. subway.

On April 19, 2001, a public meeting was held to describe and discuss the new subway alignment, the project schedule, and next steps.

In October 2001, NYCT published a Summary Report describing the full-length alternative and outlining the process by which the full-length alternative was selected.

In April 2003, the Second Ave. Subway Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement (SDEIS) was published. Public hearings on the SDEIS were held on May 12 and 13, 2003.

In April 2004, the Second Ave. Subway Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) was published.

In July 2004, the FTA issued a Record of Decision (ROD), which stated that the requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act have been satisfied for the Second Ave. Subway Project.

In July 2004, Preliminary Engineering for Phase One was completed. In December 2004, Preliminary Engineering for Phases Two, Three and Four was completed.

In April 2006, Extended and Final Preliminary Engineering was completed. In April 2006, The Federal Transit Administration authorized the MTA to begin Final Design of Phase One of the project and the Final Design contract was awarded.

33 comments

joseph menasce August 13, 2007 - 11:16 am

Can you please inform me on the design impact of the 2nd ave near 108St . This area is below the east river water level. Will it impact Franklyn ave apartment complex or the utility underground.
I am w/ a consulting engineering firm and we intend to make a boiler plant across the street. Please fill me in on the design impact on our client. Will the interruption of the utility service qualifies that complex to some grant.
Tel 212-675-8844 X 231
Thanks

Reply
grownANDsexy August 31, 2007 - 12:46 am

@ joseph menasce:
You should probably call the MTA about that one. There are also a number of city agencies that can help with that as well (or at least tell you who you should talk to)

@ 2nd Ave. Subway History:
You know what’s really F’ed up about this? is that there were elevated lines on all 3 avenues on the east side. They took down the elevated lines and then just “forgot” to replace any of them.

Do you know how cheap it would have been to do it way back when? Why bother even taking down the lines in the first place? why not leave it up (I can only imagine the property values if they did) as the ONLY working elevated train below 110 street?

Man… I wish I was born rich and powerful back then lol. I would have kept the elevated 2 avenue subway until money was promised for a subway line… and I would have kept the A line in Brooklyn elevated just to connect to Broadway Junction… man all those trains in one place would have been a sight! LOL

Reply
Joepho September 2, 2007 - 3:05 pm

Grown,

The problem was in the 1950s (when most passenger railroads were ceasing operations), no one thought 50 years ahead that these rail lines might be needed to relieve congestion on the Lex Ave line. These lines were considered eyesores and dangerous to auto traffic and hence were demolished as the operators were bankrupt. Westchester county has a similar problem with the old “Put” line which was scrapped in 1980: it would have been an outstanding commuter railroad, but most of the stations had no parking facilities, and the freight carriers had no more businesses on the line.

Now to try to condemn private property to build a railroad or to attempt such a feat in a short amount of time would be near impossible, thanks to lawsuits and other fanatical environmental/ACLU groups who oppose everything.

If you’re interested, look how Moscow is continually expanding their subway/metro system. NYC should take the lead from them and expand existing lines, in addition to studying and building new lines where feasible.

Reply
Julius K. McIntyre September 19, 2007 - 7:13 pm

Will this new proposed subway extension line system under 2nd Avenue in Manhattan have a connection to the BMT 14th Street Canarsie Line “L” Train, the Crosstown IND “GG/G”
line at the Broadway Station in Brooklyn , and the
abandoned line which the station still exist across the
8th Ave “A” Train of the 8th Independent Line at “Utica Ave” in Brooklyn? The station runs across the Utica Ave Station of the 8th Ave Independent Subway Line.

Reply
mike October 16, 2007 - 8:08 am

Joepho,

Those “fanatical” environmental groups are looking out for you, and they don’t oppose everything.

As for the ACLU, I’m not sure what they have to do with building railroads. They are busy defending your Constitutional rights, which you may have noticed, are under attack by a president who thinks that he should be Supreme Leader. You should be thanking the ACLU every damn day for their defense of this fragile democracy.

Reply
mike October 16, 2007 - 8:09 am

Anyway, I’m very excited about the SAS, and would love it if old train lines were revived!

Reply
vanshnookenraggen blog » Blog Archive » The futureNYCSubway: 2nd Avenue Subway History March 25, 2010 - 2:15 pm

[…] more detailed timeline can be found over at SecondAveSagas.com, a blog set up originally to track progress on the line but now deals with all things MTA (one of […]

Reply
The Funky Apple | A New York City Blog » Blog Archive » 2nd Ave Subway is right on track June 15, 2010 - 11:32 am

[…] hey, remember the 2nd ave subway? You know, the subway line that’s been in the works for almost 100 years? Well the MTA just wanted to us know that the first phase of the subway extension is going along […]

Reply
Urban Omnibus » Mall-terations on Allen Street October 18, 2010 - 2:49 pm

[…] Street’s rail line was part of the Second Avenue Elevated, whose underground replacement, now dubbed the T train, has been under discussion since before elevated service was discontinued in 1940 and is now […]

Reply
BORBAY » Upper East Side Photo Extravaganza: Guggenheim, MET, Paul Ryan January 7, 2011 - 9:35 am

[…] to 2nd Avenue, the promise land for over time and under […]

Reply
Levees Not War » Blog Archive » Public Works in a Time of Job-Killing Scrooges March 3, 2011 - 10:25 am

[…] Grynbaum began by reading quotations from a report on how the building of the Second Avenue subway line in Manhattan was affecting local East Side businesses, parking, etc. A spokesman from the […]

Reply
Quora September 14, 2011 - 1:08 am

Is New York building any new subway lines?…

Yes, the Metropolitan Transit Authority is building one new subway line. The Second Avenue Subway line (the “T” train) has been under construction since 2007.The line has had many setbacks since it was first planned in the 1920’s. Its first phase, t…

Reply
Building Transit Today: The Second Avenue Subway October 4, 2011 - 8:10 am

[…] photos taken by Jake Schabas, with information historical information from Second Ave. Sagas. Stay tuned for exclusive photos of the 7 Line Extension and East Side Access construction […]

Reply
Quora November 22, 2011 - 7:46 am

What is the expected completion date for the new subway on Second Avenue in NYC?…

The Second Avenue Subway line (the “T” train) has been under construction since 2007. The line has had many setbacks since it was first planned in the 1920’s. Its first phase, the 2-mile 96th to 63rd stretch of track has funding secured and is expec…

Reply
Bureaucalypse - California Farmland July 10, 2012 - 11:53 am

[…] thumbing through the history of the grandaddy of them all in the U.S.A.   Our case in point is the 2nd ave subway project in New York City, perhaps nudging out Boston’s ‘Big Dig‘ as a model of sisyphian futility, and […]

Reply
New Yorker's Best Subway Stories | Narratively November 27, 2012 - 12:01 am

[…] rumors bubbled up that the long-abandoned 2nd Avenue subway, first proposed in 1920, would finally be resurrected. One morning in 2007 I awoke and gazed across […]

Reply
Vancouver wants (and needs) a subway on Broadway « Critical Transit December 5, 2012 - 1:55 pm

[…] or build a complementary line to take some pressure off the existing service (the case behind the Second Avenue Subway). Share this: Pin ItDiggShare on TumblrPrintEmail December 5th, 2012 | Category: […]

Reply
Mad Men Recap: Learnings | Giddy Up, America May 2, 2013 - 1:17 pm

[…] Peggy & Abe are looking for a new apartment, an apartment by the proposed Second Ave subway. […]

Reply
» Underneath NYC’s Upper East Side The Hipmunk Blog May 2, 2013 - 6:31 pm

[…] 2nd Avenue Subway project has been on the table for many many years. It was first proposed in 1929 [1] but has found itself stopped and started and shelved ever since. In 2007, the 2nd Avenue line […]

Reply
Crítica del episodio 6×04 de Mad Men | La primavera de los pueblos May 7, 2013 - 9:21 am

[…] llegará pronto, para hacer al lugar más deseable. Cuarenta y cinco años después, esa línea sigue sin existir, aunque de vez en cuando se realizan trabajos de construcción. Sin embargo, la idea de Abe de […]

Reply
Episodes 5 & 6 “The Flood” and “For Immediate Release | The MadCast Pod May 10, 2013 - 6:12 pm

[…] Worthy Notes from the Pod History of the 2nd Avenue Subway […]

Reply
Building NYC’s 2nd Ave. Subway | June 18, 2013 - 10:05 am

[…] conceived originally, with the idea of an East Side train dating back to the 1920’s. According to Second Avenue Saga the train was originally planned to be built from 1930 to 1935, but was abandoned after the stock […]

Reply
Inside New York’s subway construction June 18, 2013 - 12:07 pm

[…] New York’s second avenue subway construction is in full swing. This train line has been planned for since 1929 but construction didn’t begin until 2007. […]

Reply
Building Transit Today: The Second Avenue Subway | Untapped Cities July 23, 2013 - 12:03 pm

[…] photos taken by Jake Schabas, with historical information from Second Ave. Sagas. Stay tuned for exclusive photos of the 7 Line Extension and East Side Access construction projects […]

Reply
Descending into the Second Avenue Subway Construction in NYC [PHOTOS] | Untapped Cities July 24, 2013 - 9:01 am

[…] All photos taken by Bhushan Mondkar, with historical information from Second Ave Sagas. […]

Reply
A Descent Into New York’s Remarkable Second Avenue Subway | Yolobzinga Art July 31, 2013 - 4:36 am

[…] remarkable plan has taken longer than any other in the city's history. First proposed in 1929 and again in 1951, but persistently hobbled by money woes and community oppo…, the Second Avenue Subway will open, in a first phase, in December 2016. That […]

Reply
Will de Blasio Mean a More Affordable NYC? | Connecting the Dots, What Matters Today | BillMoyers.com November 6, 2013 - 11:19 am

[…] This growth causes problems. For example, there are more people commuting to work than ever before, but the city has the same number of roads and the same number of subway tunnels. It can buy more trains, but for safety reasons, they can’t run too close to one another. The city is building a new train line parallel to a particularly congested one on Manhattan’s east side, but that project has been in the works for nearly a century. […]

Reply
Sheepshead Bites » Blog Archive How Transit Riders Continually Get Screwed » Sheepshead Bay News Blog February 17, 2014 - 1:21 pm

[…] COMMUTE: It started with continual promises to construct a Second Avenue subway and the failure to complete the IND Second System. We are currently in the sixth reincarnation of […]

Reply
How To Help Children with Asperger's in Education (Parenting Asperger's Simple Strategies Series) free downloads March 26, 2015 - 8:38 pm

How To Help Children with Asperger’s in Education (Parenting Asperger’s Simple Strategies Series) free downloads

How to Help Your Child with Aspergers Syndrome Succeed in Education gives you practical tips and strategies for children with Aspergers Syndrome in school.

Reply
???? ??? ???? ????? ???? ????? - ???? ??????? ???? August 1, 2015 - 10:31 am

[…] 2nd. Ave. Sagas […]

Reply
7 Line 34th St. extension opens - NYC on the Cheap September 12, 2015 - 7:20 am

[…] Still to come is the opening of the Second Avenue Subway.  It’s just a century overdue – proposed in the early 1900s.  Read about the saga of the Second Avenue Subway on the blog 2nd Avenue Sagas. […]

Reply
A brief history of making sure you don’t have to live anywhere near anyone you don’t want to in Los Angeles | biking about architecture January 4, 2016 - 9:38 pm

[…] Purple Line, or the fabled Subway to the Sea, is the West Coast’s answer to New York’s Second Avenue Line. It’s been in talks since the 1980s, and finally broke ground just this year. […]

Reply

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy