Home MTA Absurdity We now rejoin ‘As the Escalator Doesn’t Rise’ already in progress

We now rejoin ‘As the Escalator Doesn’t Rise’ already in progress

by Benjamin Kabak

When last we checked in on the MTA’s escalator problem in May, a few local New York papers had documented rampant elevator outages throughout the subway system, and The New York Times had issued a stunning indictment of the MTA’s escalators and elevators. The Straphangers Campaign jumped on the bandwagon, urging New York City Transit to audit their escalators.

While the MTA shouldered much of the blame for the escalator outages, as the news came out, reporters discovered that a lot of the fault fell on the supposed operators of these escalators: the owners of the buildings. You see, when the MTA and private developers get together on real estate deals above subway stations, the MTA stipulates that the management companies are responsible for maintaining the subway entrances and the methods of egress. That includes escalators as stations such as, oh, Union Square.

That Union Square escalators — next to the Food Emporium on 14th St. — were the proverbial eye of this perfect storm. The escalators have long been out of service, and the people in charge of Zeckendorf Towers are supposed to be maintaining it. But as Curbed told us in April, the Buildings Department shut down the escalators last summer, and the Zeckendorfs have opted to do nothing about it. Until today.

This afternoon, Curbed posted the below photo:

That’s right; the Zeckendorfs are doing something. They’re taking what should be a perfectly functional escalator or at the very least a staircase and turning it into an entombed nothing all because they don’t want to invest the money to fix it. At the very least, they could turn the escalators, as one Curbed commenter suggests, back into a staircase. Then, straphangers wouldn’t be faced with a giant slide.

As far as I know, the MTA could probably file a breach of contract complaint. The management company is, after all, supposed to maintain and not close their escalators. Otherwise, we’d have a regular, full-sized entrance at the one of the subway system’s most popular stations. But then again, that would be a proactive solution to something plaguing the system.

And in a way, isn’t this symptomatic of the overarching problems plaguing the MTA? When faced with a problem in which even the law is on their side, the MTA hasn’t responded as they should. When these escalators when out of service, the MTA should have used their leverage to force the Zeckendorf Towers management to fix it. Instead, these escalators are just permanently out of service, another sign of an agency — this one private — taking the MTA for a ride.

You may also like


herenthere July 11, 2008 - 7:12 pm

Looks like the MTA has to stop being a wuss and start ‘shouldering’ around to get their way.

Michael July 11, 2008 - 8:54 pm

I think they are making a slide

Ryan OHoro July 14, 2008 - 12:42 am

Wow. Just wow. This is really infuriating. At one point you could at least use the escalators as stairs… now the capacity of the entrance is cut in half permanently. Just. Wow.

Ryan OHoro July 14, 2008 - 12:46 am

An escalator can never break. It can only become stairs. You would never see an “Escalator Temporarily Out Of Order” sign, just “Escalator Temporarily Stairs. Sorry for the convenience.” – Mitch Hedberg

Be July 24, 2008 - 11:57 am

Yeah, just make it stairs and pay the MTA some fee for breach of contract. It’s a pretty terrible spot for an escalator because it’s half-exposed to the elements. I’m no expert, but I’m pretty sure escalators are not designed to work well with lots of dirt being constantly blown onto them, and rain water drainign onto it, or snow drifts piling up on it… just a thought.


Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy