Home Brooklyn Petition for F express service picking up steam

Petition for F express service picking up steam

by Benjamin Kabak


Those F express tracks sit unused, and Brooklyn residents want to see that changed.

When last I checked in on the petition to promote F service along the unused express tracks on Brooklyn’s Culver line, the movement, while presenting a very feasible plan, had yet to gain steam. Well, the last nine days have seen a whirlwind of attention, and what began as a response to a my dig at the F train has turned into a full-fledged movement.

Gary Reilly’s efforts to draw attention to an under-served and overused line have been written up in The Brooklyn Eagle, New York Metro and most thoroughly in The Brooklyn Paper. The Downtown Brooklyn Parternship, in their statement supporting Mayor Bloomberg’s congestion tax, voiced their call for F express service as well.

So the movement is growing. Newspapers and business associations are hoping on this bandwagon. So far, over 2000 residents have added their names to the petition as well. But the MTA is stonewalling. The Authority keeps insisting that they cannot restore express service to the F line until the work on the Culver Viaduct at 9th St. is completed in 2012. The Brooklyn Paper has more:

New York City Transit spokesman Charles Seaton said this week that the agency can’t consider restoring express service — which existed as recently as the early 1980s — until 2012, when a planned reconstruction of the elevated track between the Fourth Avenue and Smith and Ninth Street stations will be complete.

He said that “express service would not be possible” until then because track work associated with the job will require the G train to run to Church Avenue on the F route, taking up the track that would be available for the South Brooklyn fast lane. “New York City Transit will review the feasibility of F-line express service [when that project is complete],” he said, adding that the final decision will be based on need.

Meanwhile, Bill DeBlasio, a member of the City Council, says that the MTA is “looking into other ways to do F express” so that we don’t have to wait another five years for this much-needed service to arrive.

As The Brooklyn Paper noted, some transit studies have shown that the F express service would save up to 20 minutes for many commuters. It would increase train service to rapidly growing areas to the city on a subway line that is currently maxed out during rush hour. It’s time for Brooklyn to get this express service.

Next week, at the MTA meeting focusing on capital improvement projects, members at the forefront of this F express movement plan to bring this plan to the MTA. So the more support they have, the better the proposal will sound to the ears of those making the decision about the train service. Add your name to the petition, and let’s keep the movement going. This is a plan that will benefit everyone.

You may also like


Gary June 22, 2007 - 10:55 am

Pretty amazing stuff. I’m going to print up a handful of copies and distribute them at the MTA Board meeting next Wednesday.

Beyond this issue, it’s a matter of dedicated streams of funding for transit improvements. The congestion pricing isa step in the right direction, but greater city and state support for upgrading and expanding mass transit is a must.

Cheers Ben. Great post.

stepheneliot June 22, 2007 - 3:57 pm

Props to you, Ben! Keep posting and truthdigging to steal a phrase from Robert Sheer’s website, and let the signatures add up to a force that effects the changes necessary to run the trains more efficiently and provide Brooklyn a subway system that it deserves.

Jason Han June 24, 2007 - 1:27 pm

If they’re gonna let the F train stall and just stand there, isn’t it a waste of effort?

Todd June 25, 2007 - 1:14 am

I can’t think of anything to say other then the standard “I hate the MTA.”

Oh wait, yes I can. WTF is up with the MTA website? It’s out of service more then the subways!

Benjamin Kabak June 25, 2007 - 1:34 am


I’ve never had a problem with the MTA site. Are you sure it’s not your ISP?

ginger June 25, 2007 - 4:40 pm

Fantastic and thanks!I want to sign the petition as well.

If this express lane won’t re-open until 2012, how about alternating trains (every other train is local or express…since they seem to come in pairs every 15-30 minutes, the first could be express, the one behind it local). I don’t really know how the time differences would be-just throwing out an idea…


Leave a Comment