Home Asides With new state budget release, MTA’s finances head further south

With new state budget release, MTA’s finances head further south

by Benjamin Kabak

When the MTA institutes its sweeping package of service cuts this summer, the agency will do so in an attempt to save nearly $400 million. It’s now going to have to find double those savings to stave off economic disaster. According to the latest budget totals from New York State, the estimate revenue generated by the payroll mobility tax will now be $700 million less than expected from 2009-2011. With this news, the MTA faces even more economic uncertainty and a 2010 budget gap that will grow to at least $400 million after the cuts are instituted. At this point, fare hikes for 2011 are shaping up to be quite substantial.

Meanwhile, the ideological divide between those who want the MTA to receive proper funding is growing. In response to this news — a development that highlights the need for a long-term fix — Gene Russianoff sent out a statement again supporting a short-term stimulus fix that won’t even close this new estimated gap. “The MTA’s widening deficit makes it more important than ever for the cash-starved agency to use currently available federal stimulus money to keep running as much transit service as possible,” he said, when in fact this widening deficit makes it more important to find a stable source of year-to-year revenue and not a funding source that will dry up after it’s tapped.

On the other side of the debate is John Petro of the Drum Major Institute. In a Huffington Post piece, Petro explains why bridge tolls and congestion pricing schemes are both inevitable and beneficial for the MTA and New York. With wider gaps projected for this year and next, Petro’s is the kind of proposal transit advocates need to be supporting right now. A stimulus fix, estimated to provide under $200 million in funding, just won’t cut it right now.

You may also like


Red February 3, 2010 - 6:05 pm

Bridge tolls and congestion pricing are not going to happen in the half-year or so before the service cuts are scheduled to come in. I doubt they will happen this year, in fact, given the number of folks up for election.

And Ben, while you make a strong case that many of the proposed MTA cuts should be seen as efficiencies, what about if another $100 million in cuts come down the line? Or something equivalent to the old doomsday cuts? Is there some point at which flexing stimulus cash for operating becomes justifiable given the likelihood that job-killing transit cuts may be on the way?

Preserving transit service so people can get to work is as valid a use of stimulus funds as infrastructure investment. It’s hard for many people to take at face value a suggestion that, for example, $50 million invested in the Fulton Street Transit Center is more to the public good than $50 million invested in service during a time of economic crisis.

rhywun February 3, 2010 - 8:25 pm

Things just keep getting more “interesting”. If the economy doesn’t turn around and once again sweep the city and state’s persistent waste, fraud, and abuse under the rug, something’s gonna blow.

Anon February 3, 2010 - 9:01 pm

The idea of appropriating money from Public Parking to fund MTA should be revisted.

Public Parking Meters in NYC should be more aligned to that of private parking. The cost should be about half

and these funds should be earmarked for public transportation.

not sure where the funds are directed now… let’s say DOT gets to keep funds… ok, at least split these funds with MTA.

Abba February 3, 2010 - 11:50 pm

So what can we expect for the fare hike next year?

Brother, can you spare eight billion dimes? :: Second Ave. Sagas | A New York City Subway Blog February 4, 2010 - 1:49 am

[…] « With new state budget release, MTA’s finances head further south Feb […]

New York City February 4, 2010 - 2:30 am

[…] reading here: With new state budget release, MTA's finances head further south … – JOIN THE INVESTORS CLUB […]

State Senate, under GOP control, aims for payroll tax :: Second Ave. Sagas December 6, 2010 - 11:43 am

[…] development, first reported in February, drives home the need for a better and more reliable source of revenue for the MTA. Tom Namako at […]


Leave a Comment