Dodging a question, Lieber shows an MTA unwilling to confront its cost crisis

Well over budget and long delayed, London’s Elizabeth Line, shown here in a tour I took with Andy Byford in November, costs just one-third per kilometer than future phases of the Second Ave. Subway. (Photo by Benjamin Kabak)

Albany oversight hearings are staid and rote affairs. Every now and then, a panel of state legislators call in the technocrats in charge of state agencies to talk about the topics on the minds of those legislators. Unfortunately, those topics often run to the banal when it comes to transit and the MTA. Why is this bus stop in my district on one corner but not the other? Why isn’t the MTA building platform edge doors? When will Staten Island get better transit service?

These are questions with well-known answers, but for the sake of their constituents, our elected officials have to go through this exercise. I find it very frustrating. The Senate and Assembly could hold wall-to-wall hearings on any number of issues plaguing our transit system, but these 90-minute sessions once or a twice a year if we’re lucky is all we get. When MTA CEO and Chair Janno Lieber appeared before a joint committee panel this week, I didn’t expect much to come of it, and by and large, my low expectations were met. The session even featured Diane Savino asking why the MTA plans to build the IBX but there are no plans to build a subway to Staten Island, a topic worth its own post exploring why her constituents don’t want one and no one is currently pushing funding for it. But I digress.

Midway through Lieber appearance, one brief exchange leapt out at me. George Borello, a Republican who represents Jamestown and a district as far away from the MTA’s service area as possible, was the only member of the panel to ask about the MTA’s runaway construction costs. The exchange was brief, and the emphasis is mine:

Borello: It’s been widely reporting that MTA construction costs are up to seven times the global average. Why is that the case? And what steps is the MTA taking to address these out of control costs?

Lieber: The bigger question of how we compare to the rest of the world is part of a longer conversation, but when people throw those numbers around, they frequently don’t even look at what’s the scope. So comparing a mile of New York City subway tunnel to a rubber-wheel facility where they have three cars that carry 100 people is nonsense. So if these comparisons are going to go on, you have to do apples-to-apples work…When you look at those kinds of comparisons, frequently they are informed by nonsensical lack of effort to compare projects based on scope, technology and the conditions of work.

This is a breathtakingly dismissive answer from the MTA head, and it’s wrong. A lot of people, from advocates to journalists to researchers, have conducted rigorous examinations into the MTA’s cost problems. They have indeed compared apples to apples – they’ve compared the Elizabeth Line’s deep-bore subway tunnel underneath London to the Second Ave. Subway’s deep-bore subway tunnel underneath Manhattan – and these efforts are simply not “nonsensical” nor lacking in effort. These four sentences uttered by the MTA head to a panel of legislators during an oversight hearing tells me all I need to know about the lack of sincerity of the MTA’s cost reform efforts.

The MTA’s cost problems are well documented and rigorously documented. Brian Rosenthal of The Times produced a thorough and accessible piece four years ago analyzing how everyone from unions to contractors to public officials is to blame and how the MTA’s usual excuses – environmental review laws, powerful unions, old utilities, fire codes – don’t hold up when compared with the Parises, Madrids and Londons of the world. Alon Levy and Eric Goldwyn at Transit Costs have established a database of global transit projects that break down each by its components. These are the apples-to-apples comparisons that show the MTA paying between three or five times more per kilometer than even the second most expensive projects in the world. These are completely sensical comparisons that show out of control costs.

So why would Lieber dismiss this question out of hand when it’s one he should face every time he is called to Albany? For one, an entire ecosystem exists based on the MTA’s construction costs. Contractors in NYC are a powerful political interest group, and they would lose the most if the MTA could cut even a third of their astronomical construction costs. So the impetus to cut costs would come at a political price for Lieber’s boss. For another, cost reform is almost as impossible a task as it can be in NYC. Lieber alone can’t reform the MTA’s construction costs, and he’s overstepping his bounds to suggest the MTA is flushing money down the toilet. His job to lead to the agency, and it’s the politicians’ job to back work rule reforms and overhauls of review laws that drag down MTA construction projects. He doesn’t have the power or political backing to do any of this himself. It’s both a flaw and the purpose of the MTA as a quasi-independent government authority.

Ultimately, Borello was right to ask, and his fellow Senators should be beating the drum on this topic non-stop. The MTA will not be able to expand its network sufficiently until the costs are under control, and understanding how and why the costs are so out of control and admitting it all publicly is the necessary first step. And all those cost comparisons floating out there? They’re accurate, and they’re not nonsense. Anyone in charge of the MTA should admit that.

Comments

29 responses to “Dodging a question, Lieber shows an MTA unwilling to confront its cost crisis”

  1. The answer to the question of why the MTA’s construction costs are so high is its use of contractors. If the MTA did all construction in-house by means of a dedicated construction department, it would pay much less for this work. What’s more, we’d have cost certainty, and MTA management would exert direct oversight.

    Given the decades-long scale of the Second Avenue line, and also the possibility of Hochul’s new interboro line, our public transit agency should itself employ the large workforce it needs for these projects, instead of relying on the wasteful and thieving private sector.

    1. John R

      100% agreed. We need an in-house construction agency. I’d also advocate for a public bank that is responsible for raising funds not only for MTA capital, but other public works such as sanitation, roads, waterworks, education, housing, etc.

  2. Vicki

    That snarking at “rubber wheels” makes me think of the Montreal metro, which serves a city of a couple of million, plus suburbs. One thing I don’t miss when I’m there is the screeching of steel wheels against metal tracks when trains turn or brake suddenly.

    1. DFM

      Maybe NYC should outsource its capital construction to RAPT (Paris Transit System) since they are constructing subways at a quarter of the cost. And Paris is a very tough construction area with complex labor laws. Just hand them the job.

  3. Here is one way to learn what is going on with costs The Federal Transit Administration provides $1.5 billion in annual capital grants to the MTA. This is accomplished under the FTA Transit Award Management System (known as “TrAMS”) used to award and manage federal grants. The MTA currently manages an active portfolio of federally funded capital improvement projects and programs in open grants worth over $12 billion.

    As part of the requirements contained within all master grant agreements, using the FTA TrAMS System, the MTA, provides updated Quarterly Financial and Milestone Progress Reports to the FTA on active capital improvement projects and programs.

    Explanations for project delays and change orders over $100,000 have to be provided that they are fair and reasonable. Project delays require recovery schedules and revised interim milestones to document future completion.

    The FTA has its own independent engineering consultant firms to supplement in house staff for oversight. These companies provide both oversight and technical assistance for capital projects. The FTA assigns their own engineering consultant firms to those projects over $100 million. Engineering firms monitor the progress of these major capital projects and prepare monthly progress reports. These monthly reports are made available to MTA Chairperson Janno Lieber, HQ staff, Agency Presidents and their Chief Engineer, FTA HQ & Regional Office senior management teams and in house project oversight staff.

    Governor Hockul promised that her administration will be above board and honest. When will she promote transparency by having all of these information sources submitted to the FTA by MTA posted on their agency web site as well? Riders, taxpayers, transit advocates and transit reporters deserve nothing less.

    (Larry Penner is a transportation advocate, historian and writer who previously worked for the Federal Transit Administration Region 2 New York Office. This included the development, review, approval and oversight for billions in capital projects and programs for the MTA, NYC Transit bus and subway, Staten Island Rail Road, Long Island and Metro North Rail Roads, MTA Bus along with 30 other transit agencies in NY & NJ.)

    .

  4. Projects with more contractors and subcontractors increase the odds of greater costs. Ninety days after a contract is awarded, it is common for the prime contractor submitting a detailed construction schedule that includes the critical path for completion of the project. This is reviewed and approved by the transit agency. The critical path documents what any future delays could trigger other delays to the overall project schedule It integrates the scheduling of work to be performed by the prime contractor, other contractors and all subcontractors. If the work of one falls behind their portion of the project, it could delay the start of work by another contractor or subcontractor This, in turn would delay the overall project. The more contractors and subcontractors you have, the greater the risk something could go wrong. Just take a look at past history for the MTA LIRR $11.2 billion East Side Access to Grand Central Terminal with 36 contractors and see for yourself

    (Larry Penner — transportation advocate, historian and writer who previously worked for the Federal Transit Administration Region 2 New York Office.

  5. Hank

    I worked for 6 months on the new east side access tunnel as a construction worker . I was paid along with hundreds of other works to build this . WHAT I didn’t understand was why the MTA needed about 40 white hats to walk around as a group with an IPad checking the work. I’m sure they could have done it with 20.

  6. Max Wyss

    Mr. Borello’s comment to Lieber’s answer should have been a loud “Hähhh???”

    …followed by a harsh attack at the governor why such bullshitters are allowed at that position…

  7. Larry Littlefield

    People at New York City Transit are well aware of this issue. The reality is the MTA has been used as a piggy bank to pay for retroactive pension increases for construction pension funds decades ago, and for a variety of others.

    Meanwhile, one of the more stunning excess costs in New York is how much is spent on road maintenance Upstate, compared even to other rural states/areas such as Vermont, New Hampshire, and Maine. And how overstaffed that function is compared with other places. Something I’ve been reporting and trying to find some explanation for over the past few decades. Medicaid? Public schools? Same extremely high spending compared with other places, relative to the services received.

    I can only point out that MTA capital projects and upstate road maintenance are controlled by the same New York State legislature. And those incumbent legislators, and the incumbent Governor, are backed by every special interest in the state.

  8. This didn’t age well, did it? The purpose of congestion pricing at some point in the future was to not have to fund the MTA capital plan in some other way, without admitting the system is heading for a downward spiral. But after being bonded against for a single five-year capital plan, congestion pricing would only have postponed that downward spiral by five years.

    There is no real choice. They have arranged things that way, something I recognized two decades ago.

    http://www.ipny.org/littlefiel…..n2020.html

    Did what I could.

  9. The post makes a strong case for comparing transit projects on a like-for-like basis instead of dismissing the cost gap as a matter of scope. That same discipline helps when teams turn complex inputs into repeatable decisions: Documentation explains a practical way to structure typed questions, scores, and probabilities without hiding the assumptions.

  10. Lucia Ferrante

    Lieber’s dismissal of the cost comparisons as ‘nonsensical’ is exactly the kind of deflection that keeps the status quo intact. The Transit Costs database and Rosenthal’s reporting already did the apples-to-apples work he claims is missing. Until the MTA publicly admits the gap, no real reform will happen. Tools like the show how transparent data can drive improvement, and the MTA could learn from that mindset. Related resource: Web Dashers Level Editortps

  11. Ingrid Sorensen

    Lieber’s dismissal of the cost comparisons as “nonsensical” is exactly the kind of deflection that keeps the MTA from ever fixing its problems. The Transit Costs database and Rosenthal’s reporting are rigorous, apples-to-apples work, not lazy talking points. Until leadership admits the gap publicly, no real reform will happen. Related resource: Noomicheems

  12. Rose Armstrong

    Lieber’s demand for apples-to-apples comparisons would carry more weight if he addressed the Elizabeth Line and Second Ave. Subway example directly. Dismissing the research leaves legislators without any explanation of which costs the MTA can actually reduce. The exchange reminded me of the alors on danse meme: the conversation keeps moving while the underlying problem stays put. Borello’s question deserved a breakdown of scope, staffing and contracting costs, followed by measurable targets.

  13. Product sellers can run a clearer plate before publishing—Picture Enhancer helps tighten soft focus and uneven lighting on object photos. (Ref 8164 · 2026-10-30): denoise and sharpen photos online https://pictureenhancer.org/

  14. Need a smaller photo for email or a site upload? ImageNow compresses images in the browser so you can preview quality before you download. (Ref 8164 · 2026-10-30): resize images without installing software https://imagenow.net/

  15. Crayon textures and wobbly lines are part of the charm—Drawing to Animation keeps that look while adding gentle motion. (Ref 8164 · 2026-10-30): hand-drawn to MP4 animation https://drawingtoanimation.app/

  16. A lightweight key changer for vocalists who need a quick transpose before rehearsal, without installing a DAW. (Ref 8164 · 2026-10-30): practice tracks at slower tempo https://pitchchanger.app/

  17. The article’s comparison of station costs makes the larger point that scope and assumptions matter before drawing conclusions about value. I also appreciate the focus on asking direct questions of decision-makers. For teams building visual concepts alongside structured workflows, API Documentation is a useful reference for image-generation integrations.

  18. I was looking for more information about AI video generation and found this site useful. The content gives a clear overview of the tool and its features, making it easier to understand what it can be used for. You can also check the image to video guide for more details.

  19. The apples-to-apples point is persuasive: scope, technology, conditions, and procurement should be separated before headline cost comparisons are dismissed. That same discipline helps when comparing creative workflows; LTX 2.3 prompt examples are useful when each input and constraint is documented before judging the output.

  20. The exchange where only one legislator asked about the MTA’s runaway construction costs really stands out, and it is frustrating that hearings stay so rote. Those costs are the core issue behind most project delays. After reading long transit analysis I like to unwind with a quick game such as Coreball.

  21. The apples-to-apples comparisons have been done for years. The Second Ave. Subway vs. the Elizabeth Line deep-bore comparison is about as close to a controlled experiment as transit construction gets, and the cost gap survives every attempt to explain it away. Calling the question ‘nonsensical’ rather than engaging with the numbers says a lot about how serious the cost reform effort really is. Thanks for highlighting this exchange — Albany oversight deserves way more attention than it gets.

    P.S. If anyone needs a quick brain break between cost analyses, I’ve been unwinding on my commute with ToonTone — a clever little color-matching game that’s perfect for subway rides.

  22. Well put. The most telling moment was treating the cost question as a partisan gotcha rather than an engineering reality to interrogate. When the obvious comparisons with Paris, Tokyo or Madrid come up, the conversation pivots to scope and standards as if those were laws of nature instead of choices an agency makes. Riders keep doing the homework the authority itself should be doing, and posts like this one that keep the receipts are exactly why the scrutiny matters. Evenings spent unwinding with a small design game like ToonTone only go so far when the daytime headlines are this dispiriting, so thanks for continuing to hold the agency to its own numbers.

  23. This piece nails the core problem: as long as the MTA treats cost questions as political third rails, the capital program keeps bleeding money through inflated contracts. The peer-system per-mile cost comparison is especially damning — those benchmarks don’t lie. Real oversight would mean publishing unit-cost figures and defending the outliers, not changing the subject. On a lighter note, my commute debate group uses a Random Topic Generator when conversation stalls, though transit funding rarely needs an icebreaker with this crowd. Thanks for continuing to hold the agency’s feet to the fire.

  24. The cost crisis framing here is right — capital vs. operating budget games have let the MTA defer hard choices for decades, and Lieber dodging the question on accessibility obligations fits that pattern exactly. The ADA backlog comparison with other agencies is telling: Chicago and Boston funded theirs, New York kept relitigating. For transit researchers who spend late nights in budget documents and board minutes, I check eye fatigue with Hunter Eyes, a quick AI eye-area tool. Sharply argued as always.

  25. Solid analysis of the cost crisis. The political dodge is frustrating but not surprising given how capital projects are budgeted. On a lighter note, I make short looping animations for my transit-nerd friends with Text to GIF (it turns plain text prompts into animated GIFs in the browser) to celebrate every new station opening. Keep up the great coverage!

  26. This article really makes me wonder how the MTA can justify such outrageous costs compared to London’s Elizabeth Line. It feels like they’re completely gamedapple – playing around with numbers instead of addressing the real issues. The MTA needs to get serious about transparency and cost control before these projects become completely unmanageable.

  27. Solid read. The pattern Lieber follows – deflecting with consultant studies instead of engaging on why per-mile costs run several times above international peers – says a lot about how the MTA handles accountability. Until the agency treats cost control as a core mission rather than a political inconvenience, capital projects will keep getting more expensive no matter how much funding arrives. Mundane aside: when I step away from transit policy reading, I have been having fun with Idol Max, a little tool that turns one photo into a game-ready 3D model – a nice reminder that some software still ships fast and cheap.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *