As the MTA has engaged in a systematic elimination of station agents over the last few years, I’ve been skeptical of the impact fewer station agents would have on subway security. By and large, station agents can see only the fare-control areas and do not police platforms. Additionally, every station is still staffed at all times by at least one agent. Yet, an article in today’s Daily News shows, at least anecdotally, how fewer official personnel can have a negative impact on the straphanger experience.
Pete Donohue spent some time at the Kingsbridge Road station on the IND Concourse Line (B/D) in the Bronx and found how the MTA has “undermined that success” of the late-1980s/early-1990s security improvements. The station is dirty with liquor bottles and litter strewn about; fare evasion at the unstaffed entrance is rampant; and while robbery numbers are in line with system averages, riders say they’re concerned for their safety. “It definitely feels less safe,” Nicole Rivera said. “This is deserted.” One rider confessed to being “unnerved by the group of men who hang out near the empty booth at all hours.”
The remaining station agent, at the north end of the stop, has access to video monitors that show a nearby staircase but none that are trained upon the now-unmanned entrance. “I don’t know if anything is happening over there,” one booth worker said to the News. “If I don’t hear anything from anyone, I got to assume everything’s fine.” Much as feelings of security can drive transit ridership, so too can the illusion of an unsafe environment push those who are vulnerable away from the trains. Gene Russianoff summed it up best: “On a personal level, it doesn’t matter what the statistics say, it’s how the environment feels. If there’s no human presence, you’re more apt to be nervous. It can be creepy.” Maybe the station agents were more vital than I originally thought.
Leave a Reply